A 33-year-old man from Kingston, New York is finally behind bars in Ulster County following a gruesome incident this year involving the assault of two victims in the Town of Hurley.

Inside HMP Berwyn
Getty Images

February 2023 Incident Injures Two in Hurley, NY

The Ulster County Sheriff's Office, in their official statement following the arrest and indictment of 33-year-old Mainor E. Sagastume on attempted murder charges, indicated that the incident that put him in jail, without bail, took place in February.

Ulster County Sheriff's Office
Ulster County Sheriff's Office

It was reported that Deputies responded to a report of a violent assault on Ridge Road in the Town of Hurley. Upon their response to Ridge Road, the officers received a 911 call from the victim himself, who in an attempt to drive himself to the hospital, called 911 to report that 'he was not going to make it because he was losing a massive amount of blood.'

The report goes on to detail that the victim was located in his vehicle on Route 28, where the Ulster County Sheriff's Deputy found him with multiple life-threatening stab wounds, and thankfully, was able to apply a tourniquet and chest seals, which 'ultimately saved the victim’s life.'

Get our free mobile app

Investigation Follows February 2023 Attack in Hurley

Several agencies provided support to the Ulster County Sheriff's Office with the investigation including the US Marshals Service, Ulster Police Department, Ulster County District Attorney’s Office, Kingston Police, New York State Police, Peekskill Police, and NY/NJ HIDTA.

Investigative efforts discovered that prior to the attack on February 11th, Sagastume had allegedly been stalking a female, and confronted her in the presence of the male victim.

Sagastume attacked both the male and female victim and during the assault it is alleged Mainor Sagastume stabbed the male multiple times and then fled the scene. The Ulster County Sheriff’s Office searched for Mainor Sagastume; however through investigation it was determined he had fled the State of New York.


Reports indicate that Sagastume was indicted by a Grand Jury in Ulster County in June 2023 for Attempted Murder in the Second Degree, Assault in the First Degree, Assault in the Second Degree, Stalking in the Second Degree, all felony charges, and two counts of Stalking in the Fourth Degree, a misdemeanor.

Kingston Police Department/Facebook
Kingston Police Department/Facebook

Following the indictment, and again with the support of the United States Marshals Service Fugitive Task Force, in late July Sagastume was finally located and arrested at a residence in Lee County Florida.

Sagastume was remanded to Ulster County Jail without bail on October 12th following his extradition to New York State from Florida the day prior.

10 New York State Gangs Known For Violent, Criminal Activity

11 Worst Places To Live In New York State

WalletHub looked at the worst small cities to live in. Below are the 11 places in New York deemed the worst to live in.