LaBella Pizza Bistro New Paltz Now Closed

It is always hard to see a well-established community restaurant close their doors, especially after being around for more than three decades. The new year, though it has brought some new and exciting local business announcements to the Hudson Valley, has also come with it's fair share of heartache when it comes to business closures, and that is what recently happened in New Paltz.

Get our free mobile app

Staple New Paltz Pizza Spot Shutters

Following 35 'wonderful years,' as Maria Lisanti, owner of LaBella Pizza Bistro (and staff) shared some news via social media, 'the time has come for me to say goodbye and step into retirement from Labella Pizza Bistro.'

LaBella, on the corner of Main Street and South Manheim Blvd, has been serving New Paltz for decades, and was actually the first place I ever grabbed a slice as a first year student at SUNY New Paltz many many years ago. Sadly, ownership has announced that is is time to retire.

Maria reinforced her appreciation for the support and loyalty she received over the years, and for trusting in LaBella for all these years.

It has been one of the greatest honors of my life to serve this community. What began as a business quickly became so much more- a place where families gathered, friendships grew, memories were made, and delicious food was served! I was fortunate enough to enjoy all these moments, and I will forever cherish the friendships, laughter, and memories we’ve shared over the years. To all of you who walked through the doors over the years, Thank You!

Though no official announcement about the future of the business, or what might happen with the storefront next, Maria did share the following which is promising:

As I retire and this chapter comes to a close, I look forward to the future of the new business and its continued service to our community.

Serving 'The Best Pizza In New Paltz' For Over 30+ Years

More than just pizza, LaBella had served the New Paltz community with all sorts of delicious authentic Italian offerings for more than 30 years. In addition to on-site dining, to-go orders, LaBella also offered catering both on site and off, for all types of occasions.

The news of LaBella's closure received mixed emotions from long-time customers and community members alike. From 'congratulations,' 'thank you's,' and well wishes on retirement to sadness and questions of where to go for pizza in the area, it is clear that LaBella has left an impact on the New Paltz community and beyond.

25 Locally Owned and Small Businesses in the Hudson Valley

Small and locally owned businesses are the heartbeat of any community, and here in the Hudson Valley, we’re fortunate to have so many shaping our neighborhoods with character and care. Each one carries its own story — from a shop sparked by an owner’s lifelong comic collection to a farm-to-fork destination named after a cherished family nickname. Here are 25 of the best, ready to inspire, delight, and remind you why shopping local matters.

Gallery Credit: Grayce Journick